General

  • Tester: Filip, Stefanie
  • Date/Time: 01.08.24
  • Duration: 30 Minutes
  • Commit/Tag: 03e97dadad765070e8efcbdb4c9f1dc55479c298
  • Setup: master.permaplant.net
  • Planned tests: 27
  • Executed tests: 26
  • ✔️Passed tests: 26
  • ⚠️Problematic tests: 0
  • ❌Failed tests: 0

Error Analysis

Closing remarks

  • How is the current state of the software? Overall in a good state, minor errors and ui issues.
  • Have the quality objectives been achieved? Usability can be improved.
  • What are the consequences drawn from the current state, including: how can future errors be avoided, how can the development process be improved? Usability Tests, Mockups

Errors found

1. When logging out while in a map, 4 error toast messages get shown on screen.
2. Error has been previously specified.
3. Class 6: Cosmetic issue
4. Level 3: Correction will be done opportunistically

1. When using the measurement tool, it is not clear that the right button stops the measuring.
2. No
3. Class 6: Cosmetic issue
4. Level 3: Correction will be done opportunistically


1. When using the measurement tool, closing the bottom status bar draws a measuring to the X of the status bar.
2. No
3. Class 6: Cosmetic issue
4. Level 3: Correction will be done opportunistically


1. When changing opacity of a layer, the cursor could better indicate that the line is changeable
2. Not yet identified
3. Class 6: Cosmetic issue
4. Level 3: Correction will be done opportunistically

Test cases

  • Description: Show a selection of plants if the search input is empty.
  • Given I am on a map page with the plant layer active
  • When I have an empty search box
  • Then I can see wanted plants as results
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer opacity

  • Description: Check whether the opacity of a layer changes.
  • Given I am on a map page with a base layer image configured
  • When dragging the slider for the base layer in the layer section of the toolbar to 50%
  • Then I can see the change in opacity of the base layer image
  • When I change the size of the toolbar
  • Then I can see the slider and the filling change in size proportionally. Therefore 50% of the slider should be filled.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Base Layer

  • Description: Check whether the maps background image is displayed correctly.
  • Given I am on a map page with the base layer active
  • When I select a base layer image
  • Then I can see the base layer image on the canvas
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Grid

  • Description: Display a point grid on the screen.
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I Zoom in or out
  • Then the grid spacing is changing
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Map Editor Guided Tour

  • Description: Check whether the Guided Tour leaves the Map Editor in its original state.
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I do the Guided Tour
  • Then after I have done the Guided Tour the map is the same as before
  • Actual Result: Description of plant relations says what a red line indicates, but no red line is shown on the map.
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes: Check if all actions can be done as described.

Additional name on map: plant labels

  • Description: Test additional names being displayed properly.
  • Given I am on the map page with the plants layer active
  • When I create a new plant from the inventory.
  • Then I can see the additional name on the label when hovering over the plant.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes: The additional name must also be visible when a different account views the same map in parallel.

Additional name on map: left toolbar

  • Description: Test additional names being displayed properly.
  • Given I am on the map page with the plants layer active
  • When I create a new plant from the inventory.
  • When I click on the new plant icon.
  • Then I can see the additional name in the left toolbars heading.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes: The additional name must also be visible when a different account views the same map in parallel.

Additional name on map: updates

  • Description: Test additional names being displayed properly.
  • Given I am on the map page with the plants layer active
  • When I create a new plant from the inventory.
  • When I go to the inventory page and change the seeds name.
  • Then I can see the changes in the plant label and left toolbar.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes: The additional name must also be visible when a different account views the same map.

Layer Management: Initial Order of Layers

  • Description: Test initial order of layers
  • When I create a new map
  • Then Base Layer is at bottom of layer list and Plant Layer is on top of layer list
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Correct konva rendering of layer order on new map

  • Description: Test correct rendering order of konva layers.
  • Given I am on a new map
  • When I add a background image in Base Layer
  • When I add an overlapping rectangle in Drawing Layer
  • When I add an overlapping plant in plant layer
  • Then Plant in is front of rectangle and rectangle is in front of background image
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Renaming of layer

  • Description: Test if Drawing Layer can be renamed.
  • Given I am on a new map
  • When I rename the Drawing Layer
  • Then The new name is visible in the layer list
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Creation of new layer

  • Description: Test if new layer can be created.
  • Given I am on a new map
  • When I select a layer and create a new one
  • Then The new layer is visible above currently selected layer
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Change order of layers

  • Description: Test if the order of layers can be updated correctly.
  • Given I am on a map with 2 drawing layers with overlapping rectangles
  • When I select the upper Drawing Layer and move it below the other one
  • Then The order in the layer list is updated and the rectangle of the new upper drawing layer is shown in front of the lower one on the map.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Delete Drawing Layer

  • Description: Test if Drawing Layer can be deleted
  • Given I am on a map with some drawing on a Drawing Layer.
  • When I delete the Drawing Layer
  • Then The layer disappears from layer list and drawings are deleted from map
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Deletion of Plant Layer not possible

  • Description: Test if deletion of Plant layer is disabled
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the Plant Layer
  • Then Button to delete layer is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Deletion of Base Layer not possible

  • Description: Test if Deletion of Base layer is disabled
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the Base Layer
  • Then Button to delete layer is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Undo deletion

  • Description: Test if deleted layer can be restored
  • Given I am on a map with some drawing on a drawing layer.
  • When I delete the drawing layer
  • Then Layer disappears from layer list and drawings are deleted from map
  • When I press undo
  • Then Layer appears again at same position as it was before deletion and drawings are visible again.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Top layer cannot be moved up

  • Description: Test if the top layer cannot be moved up
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the top layer.
  • Then Button to to move layer up is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Bottom layer cannot be moved down

  • Description: Test if the bottom layer cannot be moved down
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the bottom layer.
  • Then Button to to move layer down is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Renaming of Plant Layer not possible

  • Description: Test if Renaming of Plant layer is not possible
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the Plant Layer
  • Then Button to rename layer is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Layer Management: Renaming of Base Layer not possible

  • Description: Test if Renaming of Base layer is not possible
  • Given I am on a new map.
  • When I select the Base Layer
  • Then Button to rename layer is disabled
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Heatmap (only in dev branch)

  • Description: Test whether the heatmap endpoints generates the image correctly.
  • Given I am on a map page with the plant layer active
  • When I start planting a plant
  • Then I see suitable places for that plant
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result:
  • Notes:

Map Overview: More than 30 Maps should be visible

  • Description: Test that pagination works on the map overview screen
  • Given I am on the map overview screen
  • When I create more than 30 maps
  • Then I can see all maps after scrolling to the bottom of the page.
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Measurement: Measure a distance

  • Description: Test whether distance can be measured successfully
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I click on the measurement button
  • When I measure a distance
  • Then I see a measurement line
  • Then I see the measured distance
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Measurement: Cancel measurement without deleting measurements

  • Description: Verify that measured distances don't disappear when the measurement mode is canceled using the button in the status panel.
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I click on the measurement button
  • When I measure a distance
  • When I cancel the measurement mode using the status panel
  • Then the measurement layer is no longer active
  • Then I can still see the measured distance
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Measurement: Cancel measurement and delete all measurement lines

  • Description: Verify that measured distances disappear when the measurement mode is canceled using the measurement button.
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I click on the measurement button
  • When I measure a distance
  • When I cancel the measurement mode using the measurement button in the toolbar
  • Then I can no longer see the measured distance
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes:

Measurement: Delete measurements after measurement mode is deactivated

  • Description: Verify that measured distances don't disappear when the measurement mode is canceled using the button in the status panel.
  • Given I am on a map page
  • When I click on the measurement button
  • When I measure a distance
  • When I cancel the measurement mode using the status panel
  • When I click on the measurement button
  • Then I can no longer see the measured distance
  • Actual Result:
  • Test Result: ✔️
  • Notes: